Schumer and Van Hollen Dig In as Senate Leadership Race Intensifies
The race to lead Senate Democrats sharpened on Tuesday as Chuck Schumer and Chris Van Hollen lobbied colleagues face to face in Washington, their first encounter since Mr Van Hollen challenged the long-serving leader last week.
As The Washington Post reported, the two men found themselves in the same room on Tuesday at the Democrats’ weekly Capitol lunch — their first meeting since Van Hollen announced his bid on 12 November. Both left claiming momentum ahead of the secret-ballot vote on 1 December.
A first meeting since the challenge
Mr Schumer, 75, has led Senate Democrats for a decade, since 2017. Mr Van Hollen, 67, of Maryland, won his Senate seat in 2016 and is running on a message of change after Democrats recaptured the Senate in the midterm elections on 3 November.
Supporters Abdul El-Sayed of Michigan and Peggy Flanagan of Minnesota have just won their first terms, and Mr Van Hollen has pledged to lift up the newest senators’ voices.
“I really am worried that we might blow what could be a huge opportunity to deliver for the American people,” Mr Van Hollen told reporters.
Mr Schumer’s allies say it makes little sense to remove the leader who helped Democrats retake the Senate with their largest majority since the Obama administration.
“The Democrats are the only party in the country, in the world, where you can flip double the number of seats anybody, even the biggest optimist, thought was possible — and then there’s a revolt [against] the person who helped lead that,” Senator John Hickenlooper of Colorado told reporters. Mr Hickenlooper has not committed to either man.
Competing counts, and a secret ballot
More than a dozen current and newly elected senators have committed to backing Mr Schumer, who said on Tuesday he is confident he has enough votes.
Four Democrats have publicly backed Mr Van Hollen, who has said nearly a dozen more support him privately. Most Senate Democrats have not revealed whom they plan to support — an opening, Mr Van Hollen argues.
On Sunday, Mr Van Hollen called reports that he cannot win “a bunch of nonsense”, describing the contest as “a wide open race”.
Either man will need at least 28 votes to win if every eligible member of the Democratic caucus is voting. Newly elected senators may vote, while outgoing ones may not. Senator Amy Klobuchar of Minnesota cannot vote, as she is leaving the Senate after being elected governor and will not appoint a successor until January.
The secret ballot means neither camp can be certain of its votes. Senator Dick Durbin of Illinois, the retiring No. 2 Senate Democrat, warned that senators do not always vote as they say they will.
“Having stood for election several times when it was contested within the caucus, that happens regularly,” he told reporters.
Reports have said Mr Schumer’s allies have discussed moving the vote; Mr Van Hollen called that “a sign of weakness”.
Change versus continuity
Mr Van Hollen, an outspoken progressive backed by Senator Bernie Sanders of Vermont, says his challenge is not rooted in ideology. He personally supports Medicare for All and scrapping the filibuster, but says he would let the caucus decide.
A handful of Democrats say they will not vote for Mr Schumer but have not publicly backed Mr Van Hollen, including Senator-elect Adam Hamilton of Kansas, who told NBC News’s “Meet the Press” he wants “a leader who can lead from the center, somebody who can bring Republicans and Democrats together.”
Senator Cory Booker of New Jersey, who has not endorsed, called the fight “a family conversation”; Senator Peter Welch of Vermont, also uncommitted, chose a different metaphor.
“Did you ever run for class president?” Mr Welch quipped.
Senator-elect Annie Andrews of South Carolina, a paediatrician, warned the fight could distract the party, comparing it to surgeons arguing outside a trauma bay while a patient bled out: “when really what we need is someone just to stop the bleeding.”
Senator Tim Kaine of Virginia was unconcerned. “We’re Democrats,” Mr Kaine said. “We believe in democracy. It’s a healthy process.”
A contest with little precedent
It is the first contested election for Democratic Senate leader since 1994, when Tom Daschle beat Chris Dodd by one vote, and the first challenge to a sitting leader since 1984, when Lawton Chiles failed to oust Robert Byrd, according to the Senate Historical Office.
Mr Schumer was first elected to the Senate in 1998 and has not said whether he will seek a sixth term in 2028.
What happens next
Senate Democrats will settle the race by closed ballot on 1 December. The winner will lead a 56-seat majority when the new Congress convenes in January, including the seats of independents Bernie Sanders and Angus King, after Mary Peltola won a Senate seat in Alaska.