Advertise with NationWire
728 × 90 Leaderboard
Advertise Here
Technology

Huawei Trial Nears Verdict as Jury Prepares to Deliberate in Brooklyn

Advertise with NationWire
300 × 250 Medium Rectangle
Advertise Here

The racketeering conspiracy trial of Huawei Technologies approached its end on Tuesday, the Associated Press reported, after a prosecutor told jurors the Chinese telecommunications giant helped Iran spy on its citizens and stole from American companies, and a defence lawyer accused the United States of embracing a false narrative.

The jury in Brooklyn federal court was expected to begin deliberations on Wednesday, bringing a close to a trial that has run for two months and has put one of the world’s largest technology companies in the dock on charges first announced in early 2019.

Prosecutors: two decades of crime

Assistant US Attorney Meredith Arfa delivered the government’s closing argument on Monday, telling jurors that Huawei had encouraged a workforce of more than 200,000 people in 170 countries to “lie, cheat and steal” for a competitive advantage to grow and protect its business.

“For 20 years, Huawei committed a pattern of crimes targeted at American companies, the American financial system and the American government,” Arfa said, according to Reuters.

Prosecutors accuse Huawei of scheming to defraud HSBC and other banks about its business in Iran, and of conspiring to steal trade secrets from five US technology companies. The company was also indicted as a criminal enterprise, a charge more commonly associated with organised crime prosecutions.

Arfa told the jury that Huawei had provided Iran with the equipment to spy on its citizens, and that the government had proved beyond a reasonable doubt that the company operated as a criminal enterprise.

Defence: a case built backwards

Defence attorney Brian Heberlig gave the closing argument for Huawei on Tuesday, arguing that prosecutors had put a “sinister spin” on the company’s ordinary business activities and, after two months of testimony, had failed to prove the criminal charges.

Heberlig told jurors that federal prosecutors “decided Huawei was a criminal enterprise” and built a case from that premise.

“They began with guilt and worked backwards,” Heberlig said. “When the evidence didn’t fit, they moved the goalposts.”

He credited Huawei’s remarkable growth to its success in engineering, investment, innovation and competition, and said prosecutors had built their case in part by focusing on acts of wrongdoing by a few employees who were fired after their misdeeds were discovered.

He also argued that prosecutors sometimes blamed the company for gaining access to competitors’ intellectual property when the materials were already public. “You can’t steal a secret that isn’t secret,” he said.

A company barred from US networks

Huawei is the world’s largest supplier of equipment for wireless telecom networks, but it is not allowed to sell equipment to US carriers over fears it poses a security risk. It has also been blacklisted by other Western allies, including Canada and Britain.

The company makes phones and other consumer electronics, but it has been cut off from other lines of business. More recently, it has expanded into chipmaking as the boom in artificial intelligence fuels demand for microprocessors, a shift that places it at the centre of the contest over advanced chips.

During President Donald Trump’s first term, his administration raised national security concerns about Huawei and began lobbying Western allies against including the company’s products in their next-generation high-speed wireless networks. The US announced the criminal charges in early 2019 and has since expanded the allegations.

Chinese officials have said the US has engaged in “economic bullying” and improperly used national security as a pretext for “oppressing Chinese companies.”

What the verdict could mean

The jury will deliver its verdict as US-China tensions heat up in the battle over artificial intelligence and amid a fragile trade truce between the two countries. Trump is in China this week for a meeting with Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin, a reminder that the case is being decided against the backdrop of the wider contest between Washington and Beijing.

A conviction would mark one of the most significant corporate criminal verdicts in US history and could deepen the restrictions already placed on Huawei’s global business. An acquittal would be a major defeat for a prosecution that has been pursued across two administrations.

For now, the case rests with 12 jurors in Brooklyn, who must decide whether the evidence showed a criminal enterprise — or a company whose success prosecutors could not accept.

Advertise with NationWire
320 × 50 Mobile Banner
Advertise Here

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *