Court Blocks Pentagon From Discharging 27 Transgender Troops
A divided federal appeals court on Tuesday blocked the Pentagon from discharging 27 transgender service members, refusing to delay a ruling that the military’s ban likely violates the constitutional guarantee of equal protection.
The 2-1 decision by a three-judge panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit puts the court’s 1 June ruling into effect at once. It revives a preliminary injunction first issued in March 2025 and bars the Pentagon from forcing out the troops who sued in Talbott v. United States while their case continues. GLAD Law reported that the court denied the administration’s request to halt the June ruling while it asks the Supreme Court to take the case, and ordered the decision to take effect immediately.
“Three chances” to justify the ban
Writing for the majority, Circuit Judge Robert Wilkins, partially joined by Judge Judith Rogers, found the policy was designed to exclude troops based on gender identity. Wilkins noted the Pentagon had three opportunities to explain what danger the service members posed — before the trial judge, on appeal, and again when it asked the court to delay its ruling — and had not identified one. Judge Justin Walker, appointed by President Donald Trump, dissented and would have granted the stay.
In June, the majority wrote that the policy appeared driven by “the bare desire to harm a politically unpopular group” rather than legitimate military needs. The June ruling found the ban likely violates the equal protection component of the Fifth Amendment’s Due Process Clause.
The 27 plaintiffs were all on administrative leave when the order arrived, and several faced board hearings that could have ended their careers. Together they have served more than 130 years and earned more than 80 commendations, their lawyers said.
What the order does — and does not — cover
The protection applies only to the 27 named plaintiffs who are already serving. It does not allow new transgender recruits to enlist: the June ruling lifted the injunction for those seeking to join, and that part of the ruling stands.
The case, Talbott v. United States, was the first lawsuit filed against President Donald Trump’s January 2025 executive order targeting transgender service members and the Pentagon policy that followed, issued by Secretary of War Pete Hegseth and widely known as the “Hegseth Policy”.
The fight now moves to the Supreme Court — and back to trial
The administration has asked the Supreme Court to review the June decision, and the justices will consider the petition at their 4 December conference. The Supreme Court had earlier allowed the ban to take effect while litigation continued in a separate case.
In the district court, meanwhile, U.S. District Judge Ana Reyes is moving the case toward a two-week bench trial starting on 4 January 2027, which will proceed as a class action. On Monday, Reyes gave the administration 28 days to hand over internal records about how the ban was drawn up and authorised the plaintiffs’ lawyers to question former Army Secretary Dan Driscoll under oath. Out.com reported that Reyes is moving ahead with the trial while the Supreme Court petition remains pending.
The troops are represented by the National Center for LGBTQ Rights and GLAD Law, which welcomed the order.
A wider legal and political fight
The ruling is the latest in a string of court and ballot fights over gender policy. Washington voters approved a ban on trans girls in girls’ school sports this month, and Colorado voters approved Proposition 135, banning gender-related surgeries for minors. Democratic attorneys general have meanwhile used state lawsuits challenging federal policies to test the administration in court.
The administration could still ask the full D.C. Circuit to rehear the case, though its Supreme Court petition is already pending.
Frequently asked questions
Who is protected by Tuesday’s order? The 27 transgender service members who sued in Talbott v. United States. All were already serving; the order does not open enlistment to new transgender recruits.
What did the court decide in June? A D.C. Circuit panel ruled the Pentagon’s ban likely violates the equal protection guarantee of the Fifth Amendment and upheld an injunction blocking discharges of serving troops.
What happens next? The Supreme Court will consider the administration’s petition at its 4 December conference. A two-week bench trial in the district court is scheduled to begin on 4 January 2027.
Why did the judges refuse the stay? Judge Wilkins wrote that the Pentagon had three opportunities to explain what danger the troops posed and had not identified one.