Advertise with NationWire
728 × 90 Leaderboard
Advertise Here
World

ICC Closes Afghanistan Probe Into Alleged US Troop Crimes

Advertise with NationWire
300 × 250 Medium Rectangle
Advertise Here

Judges at the International Criminal Court have formally closed the original Afghanistan investigation, ending the line of inquiry that could have examined alleged crimes by United States troops and intelligence personnel.

The decision, issued on Thursday, 12 November and made public on Friday, directs the court’s Registrar to close the records of the Situation in Afghanistan. Prosecutors have appealed, and the court’s Appeals Chamber has yet to set a date to rule.

The ruling closes a case that has been at the centre of a years-long dispute between Washington and The Hague over whether an international court can investigate Americans for alleged crimes committed during the war in Afghanistan.

What the judges decided

The decision by Pre-Trial Chamber I closes the original investigation in full. That inquiry covered alleged crimes by US troops and CIA personnel, Afghan government forces, the Taliban and other armed groups, dating back to 2002.

It also closes the probe into the Islamic State Khorasan militia, known as ISIS-K, which had been folded into the same investigation.

The judges said prosecutors had not shown they would be able to effectively investigate the allegations apart from the court’s newer Taliban-focused inquiry. Court documents cited “significant limitations to the Prosecution’s ability to conduct its investigations and secure evidence”.

The closure does not stop the separate investigation into alleged crimes by the Taliban since their return to power in August 2021, known as the Situation in Afghanistan II. That case continues, and the four arrest warrants issued against Taliban leaders remain in effect.

A case that lay dormant for years

The Afghanistan investigation was authorised in March 2020, when the court’s Appeals Chamber ruled that an investigation should go ahead. It covered alleged crimes from 1 May 2003, the day Afghanistan joined the Rome Statute, the treaty that created the court.

According to Human Rights Watch, the prosecutor’s allegations concerning US military and CIA personnel covered torture, cruel treatment, treatment that offended human dignity, and rape and other sexual violence. No American was ever charged, and the court never reached a verdict on any named person.

The US-troops line had lain dormant since 2021, when prosecutor Karim Khan deprioritised it and shifted the court’s attention towards the Taliban. Earlier this year, judges ordered prosecutors to split the Afghanistan inquiries into two separate probes — one focusing on alleged crimes by the Taliban since 2021, and the other on the original investigation.

The decision is not an exoneration. It does not establish whether any alleged crimes occurred, and it does not change the court’s founding statute or its claimed jurisdiction over US nationals.

Washington’s long-running dispute with the court

The United States is not a party to the Rome Statute and does not recognise the court’s claimed jurisdiction over US personnel. The dispute has sharpened this year: the United States has imposed institutional sanctions against the court, citing US opposition to arrest warrants issued for Israeli officials and the investigation into actions of US soldiers in Afghanistan.

Washington has also sanctioned 13 current and former court staff over the US-personnel probe and the Israeli warrants.

Secretary of State Marco Rubio has previously said: “President Trump will never allow the International Criminal Court to prosecute Americans.”

It is unclear whether formally closing part of the Afghanistan case will be enough to ease American concerns, since the closure does not change the court’s founding statute. The prosecutor’s appeal means the question of whether the original investigation stays closed will now be tested before the Appeals Chamber.

What happens next

The prosecutor’s office told Reuters and the Associated Press that it has appealed the decision, but it gave no further details. No date has been set for the appeal to be heard.

Meanwhile, the Taliban-focused investigation continues, including a 2024 referral concerning crimes against women and girls since the Taliban takeover. The court’s attention in Afghanistan will now be concentrated there, while the question of accountability for the war’s earlier years remains unresolved.

The ruling comes in a week when American courts have also been at the centre of major disputes: a judge blocked a deportation flight that would have sent Afghans to the Taliban, and the Supreme Court agreed to review the administration’s border asylum restrictions. Like those cases, the ICC decision turns on a question of how far a court’s reach extends — and who gets to decide.

Advertise with NationWire
320 × 50 Mobile Banner
Advertise Here

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *