Trump’s Judge Blitz Hits Republican Resistance in Lame-Duck Senate
WASHINGTON — President Donald Trump’s last-minute push to fill the federal bench before Democrats take control of the Senate in January is running into resistance from an unexpected quarter: his own party.
Reuters reported on Sunday that Republican senators in three states have blocked or cast doubt on judicial nominees chosen for their home states, slowing a confirmation drive that Senate Majority Leader John Thune has called a top priority for the lame-duck session.
Senate Republicans have confirmed 57 of Trump’s judicial nominees in his second term, cementing a conservative imprint on the judiciary. But 23 nominees remain pending, and with Congress due to end on 3 January — when every unconfirmed nomination is returned to the president — the White House is racing the calendar.
Arkansas: the White House gives in
The first setback came in Arkansas, where the White House on Tuesday took the rare step of withdrawing US District Judge Lee Rudofsky’s nomination to the St Louis-based 8th US Circuit Court of Appeals, replacing him with Arkansas Supreme Court Justice J. Cody Hiland.
Arkansas Senators John Boozman and Tom Cotton had opposed Rudofsky and pressed for Hiland instead. Rudofsky, a first-term Trump appointee, is known for a ruling that weakened enforcement of a major voting rights law. Hiland had said in August that he had been offered a trial court nomination, which he declined.
Texas and Oklahoma: blue slips withheld
In Texas, Senator John Cornyn has declined to commit to supporting T. Elliot Gaiser, Trump’s nominee for a federal judgeship in Dallas. Gaiser, who comes from Ohio, was selected without the usual senator-driven screening in Texas. He now leads the Justice Department’s Office of Legal Counsel, which has issued opinions endorsing some of the most controversial elements of Trump’s agenda.
Without a blue slip from Cornyn — the form home-state senators return to the Judiciary Committee to signal support — Gaiser cannot appear at a committee hearing scheduled for Wednesday.
In Oklahoma, Senator Alan Armstrong first returned a favourable blue slip for Zach West, a lawyer in the state attorney general’s office, then withdrew it. West has won praise from conservative legal activists for defending abortion restrictions and backing religious schools’ participation in Oklahoma’s charter school programme.
“We put up a lot of really qualified candidates that we sent to the White House, and they basically ignored that and just put through their one,” Armstrong said.
Senator Thom Tillis of North Carolina, who sits on the Judiciary Committee, is backing Armstrong’s opposition, leaving West short of the votes to clear the committee when it next decides whom to advance on Tuesday.
‘That’s not how it works here’
Tillis, who has a fractured relationship with Trump, told reporters on Thursday that the White House has at times told senators: “This is our guy, I hope you’ll get on board.”
“That’s not how it works here,” he said. “They should expect they’re going to get this response.”
Tillis said senators deserved more “respect” from the White House in selecting judges for their states. “When I’ve got two Republicans from the state telling me to move on it, I move on it,” he said. “If I have one or more asking me not to, then I’m not.”
Tillis is retiring, and Cornyn lost a primary to a Trump-backed challenger. Both are in their final days in office and sit on the Judiciary Committee, where one Republican defection can leave a nominee short of the votes to advance.
Armstrong leaves the Senate on 30 November and will be replaced by Senator-elect Kevin Hern, a Republican who could take a different position on West. Tillis said that, for now, he will keep blocking the nominee.
What happens next
The Senate confirmed its first judicial nominee of the lame-duck session on Thursday. On Monday, the full Senate votes on US District Judge Daniel Domenico of Colorado, nominated to the Denver-based 10th US Circuit Court of Appeals. The Judiciary Committee decides on Tuesday which nominees to advance, and Gaiser’s hearing is set for Wednesday.
The White House remains publicly confident: “We expect all judicial nominees pending in the Senate to be confirmed this year,” a White House official said.
Senator Dick Durbin, the committee’s top Democrat, said Republicans had dropped the usual waiting period for nominees’ paperwork to seat Texas judges before Senator-elect James Talarico takes office. Chairman Chuck Grassley replied that Democrats plan to stonewall Trump’s judges once they take over, noting that Democrats confirmed 22 judges in the lame-duck session of 2024.
The stakes are lasting: federal judges serve for life. Trump made 234 judicial appointments in his first term, including three members of the Supreme Court’s current 6-3 conservative supermajority, and roughly one-third of active federal judges are now his appointees. The confirmation fight comes as Trump has separately asked the Supreme Court to curb judges’ power to void federal rules nationwide.
The coming weeks will decide how far that imprint extends before the new Democratic majority is sworn in, after the party won at least 54 seats in the 3 November midterm elections.