Brooklyn DA Opens Criminal Inquiry Into Flatbush Collapse That Killed Eight
Brooklyn’s district attorney has opened a criminal investigation into the collapse of a three-storey building in Flatbush that killed eight people, including two children, after city records showed contractors at the construction site next door violated a stop-work order earlier this year.
The building collapsed on Wednesday afternoon, falling into an excavation pit at the construction site beside it shortly after 4 p.m. on 11 November. Police on Thursday night released the names of all eight victims, and 18 people were injured, including four firefighters. Rescue operations have now ended, and the focus has shifted to how the building came down — and who, if anyone, should face criminal charges.
A criminal inquiry, but no charges yet
Brooklyn District Attorney Eric Gonzalez is investigating whether criminal conduct contributed to the deaths, The New York Times reported on Friday. Prosecutors are examining whether contractors, developers or other parties failed to take the precautions required to protect surrounding properties during demolition and excavation.
No charges have been filed, and the opening of an investigation is not a finding of wrongdoing. But the inquiry, opened two days after the collapse, puts the companies behind the neighbouring project under formal criminal scrutiny while engineers still work to establish the physical cause of the failure.
A stop-work order, a $10,000 fine — and work that went on
City records reviewed after the collapse show a troubling history at the site next door, 2625 Bedford Avenue. Department of Buildings inspectors ordered demolition stopped there on 20 March after finding inadequate overhead protection for neighbouring buildings. When inspectors returned on 23 April, they discovered demolition had continued despite the order.
N Tech Design of America, the demolition contractor, received a $10,000 penalty for violating the restriction. The city lifted the stop-work order on 8 May after the violations were corrected, and records show the fine was paid in October, according to Law Commentary’s account of the city records.
Excavation for the new building’s cellar began on 10 September, about two months before the collapse. A pre-construction survey conducted on 5 March had already documented cracks and other deficiencies along the exterior walls of 1321 Flatbush Avenue, rating the north facade in poor condition. Investigators are now examining whether excavation affected the foundation of a structure whose walls already showed signs of damage.
The city had approved excavation and foundation work for a three-storey building at 2625 Bedford Avenue. A separate proposal called for a nine-storey mixed-use development, but the larger project had not received approval. Townhouse Builders Inc., the project’s general contractor, previously faced lawsuits alleging damage to neighbouring properties during separate construction projects in Manhattan and Brooklyn. The company denied the claims in the Manhattan case, which appears to have been resolved outside court.
The victims, and a citywide sweep
The eight people killed were Nicole Daniela Salvada Rodriguez, 9; Kevin Santiago Reyes Gonzalez, 10; Gabriel Siguencia, 22; Barry Mamadou, 23; Jose Luis Caguana Cosquillo, 26; Edgar Sapon, 26; Juan Daniel Salvada Guzman, 31; and Ndiaye Mamadou, 31. Two of the dead were construction workers.
Among them was a father, Juan Daniel Salvada Guzman, who died with his nine-year-old daughter Nicole and her ten-year-old cousin Kevin. A cousin told the New York Post that the family had stayed inside out of fear of immigration enforcement.
Mayor Zohran Mamdani has ordered inspections of more than 160 construction sites linked to six entities involved in the demolition and excavation project, and the city has commissioned an independent engineering investigation into the collapse. Buildings at 1323, 1325 and 1327 Flatbush Avenue remain subject to vacate orders while engineers assess their stability.
The disaster has also drawn attention to staffing shortages at the Department of Buildings, which had 168 vacant positions out of 1,855 authorised jobs as of Friday. City Council Speaker Julie Menin has called for those vacancies to be filled as officials examine the city’s enforcement of construction safety rules.
What caused the collapse is still unknown
The formal cause of the collapse has not been determined. A Department of Buildings inspection notice initially cited “unsafe construction operations” at the neighbouring site, although the department later withdrew that finding as premature. The Real Deal reported that building trades unions have joined grieving families in demanding better safety measures and justice for the victims, after a house fire in Sunset Park earlier this month and a school aide charged with murder in Brooklyn added to a grim run of news for the borough.
For now, work at the excavation site is halted, the neighbouring buildings stand empty, and the central question — whether the digging next door brought down a weakened building, or whether the building was already failing — remains with the engineers and, now, with Brooklyn prosecutors.