Shane Gillis Breaks Silence on SNL Monologue Backlash
Comedian Shane Gillis has finally addressed the backlash over his Saturday Night Live monologue, saying he was surprised by the reaction and that the show never approved the material in advance.
Gillis, 38, spoke about the October episode on The Joe Rogan Experience, released on 13 November, more than a month after he hosted the NBC sketch show on 10 October.
The joke that started it
The controversy centred on a passage in Gillis’s opening monologue about going to a public gym. Describing himself as an out-of-shape man among regular gym-goers, he said: “I haven’t been to the gym in so long, I didn’t know women just dress like whores now?”
The line drew groans in the studio and a wave of criticism on social media, where some viewers called it misogynistic. LADbible reported that Gillis defended the show itself while offering no apology for the routine. The Spun reported that he admitted he had been surprised by the scale of the criticism.
Gillis also used the monologue to joke about his weight, material he later described as the bulk of the set. The reaction did not stop there: cast member Inde Navarrette answered back in her own monologue in the show’s Halloween episode, and longtime cast member Kenan Thompson was among those who reacted publicly.
“A solid C minus”
Speaking to Rogan, Gillis said he had warned the show’s staff before the broadcast that the monologue was not his strongest work, but that he had promised them it would not cause trouble.
“The whole time, I was like, ‘Fellas, I’m giving you a solid C minus of a monologue, but I promise there’s no controversy. I’m calling myself fat for f***ing 10 minutes. That’s it,'” he said.
He also pushed back on the idea that the show had signed off on the jokes beforehand. “Not to defend SNL, they don’t approve it. I mean, they could shut it down,” he said, explaining that comedians generally write their own monologues rather than submitting a script for approval. He said he had performed similar material at New York’s Comedy Cellar about a week before the broadcast.
On the gym joke itself, Gillis said he did not have a problem with how women dress at the gym, adding that the reaction “obviously had a lot to do with the climate”. He said the first thing he did after the backlash was delete his social media. “The first time I got fired, I kept social media and in my head I was like, ‘That guy talked s***.’ This time, I just deleted everything immediately. So, I don’t really know,” he said.
A complicated history with SNL
The episode was Gillis’s third time hosting Saturday Night Live since a brief and bruising first encounter with the show. He was announced as a new cast member in 2019, then fired days later after clips of him using racial slurs resurfaced.
He returned as host in 2024 and again in 2025, and the October 2026 appearance completed a comeback that had seemed unlikely when he was dismissed.
NBC, which broadcasts Saturday Night Live, has been contacted for comment on Gillis’s account of how monologues are handled.
What happens next
Gillis gave no sign the episode would change how he works, and the row has kept Saturday Night Live in the headlines through a busy season for live comedy and music.
Whether the show invites him back for a fourth hosting turn is now an open question. For now, Gillis has said his piece: the monologue was, in his own assessment, mediocre, the controversy was unexpected, and the material was his own.
Frequently asked questions
What did Shane Gillis say in his SNL monologue?
During the 10 October episode, Gillis joked about going to a public gym and said he had not realised women “just dress like whores now”. The line drew groans in the studio and criticism online.
What did Gillis say on The Joe Rogan Experience?
Appearing on the 13 November episode, he said he was surprised by the backlash, rated the monologue “a solid C minus”, and said Saturday Night Live does not approve hosts’ monologues in advance.
Was Gillis fired from Saturday Night Live before?
Yes. He was announced as a cast member in 2019 and fired days later after past offensive remarks resurfaced. He has since hosted the show three times, in 2024, 2025 and October 2026.
Did Gillis apologise for the joke?
No. He said he did not have a problem with how women dress at the gym, but he did not apologise for the routine itself.