Cornyn Blocks Trump Judicial Nominee for Texas in Blue-Slip Standoff
Outgoing Republican Senator John Cornyn of Texas has moved to block one of President Donald Trump’s final judicial nominations, withholding the blue slip that would allow Justice Department official Elliot Gaiser to advance towards a federal judgeship in Dallas.
Cornyn told The Associated Press on Wednesday that he has not returned the blue slip for Gaiser, a top official at the Justice Department who was nominated for the Dallas-area vacancy earlier this month, and that he does not plan to do so. A blue slip is effectively a permission slip from a nominee’s home-state senators, and withholding it gives a senator a powerful veto over a president’s court picks.
The move is the latest setback for the White House as the Republican-led Senate scrambles to fill remaining vacancies in the federal courts before Democrats take control of the chamber on 3 January.
A lifetime appointment, without consultation
Cornyn, who sits on the Senate Judiciary Committee, was blunt about his objections. “He’s not from Texas. He hasn’t been vetted. And this is a lifetime job, and there’s better qualified people to hold that job,” he said in an interview on Wednesday.
“This is part, of course, of the constitutional responsibility of senators in the Senate to provide advice and consent. But it’s hard to provide advice and consent when there’s zero consultation, which happened in that case.”
Gaiser, 37, leads the Justice Department’s Office of Legal Counsel. According to his nominee questionnaire, he was first contacted by Texas Senator Ted Cruz’s staff about becoming a federal judge on 4 November, the day after the election. Cornyn has repeatedly raised concerns about the nomination process, noting that Gaiser has not been vetted by the bipartisan federal judicial evaluation committee traditionally used in Texas.
Speaking at an event hosted by The Atlantic on Tuesday, ahead of Wednesday’s hearing, Cornyn put it more broadly: “The Senate’s not supposed to be a rubber stamp, and what I’ve said is we have been too often.”
Cornyn did not address Gaiser’s nomination at Wednesday’s hearing, even as he expressed support for Trump’s separate decision to nominate Texas Supreme Court Justice James Sullivan to a federal judgeship after Sullivan was defeated by a Democrat in the recent election.
Cornyn’s preferred pick
The Texas senator has been recommending a different candidate for the Dallas seat: Fort Worth lawyer Steve Fahey. Fahey served in the US Attorney’s Office for the Northern District of Texas from 2003 until 2021, was a partner at Kirkland and Ellis, and started his own firm in 2024.
Cornyn said the White House has requested information about Fahey. He said he did not know whether Gaiser would be formally withdrawn.
The senator was sympathetic towards the nominee himself. “He’s a very bright young man, and I think has a very bright future,” Cornyn said of Gaiser. “I kind of feel bad that he’s been used basically as a pawn in this process.”
He stressed that he did not want to leave the court seat vacant. A White House official said in a statement that it expects all of Trump’s judicial nominees to be confirmed by the end of the year.
A lame-duck scramble
Cornyn’s decision marked the latest instance of a Republican senator declining to support a White House-backed judicial nominee from their own home state during the lame-duck session. NationWire previously reported on the growing Republican resistance to the White House’s post-election judges blitz, as senators who lost their seats or are leaving office weigh how far to go in confirming lifetime appointments before the new Congress is seated.
The confirmation battle has become one of the sharpest fights of the lame-duck period. The Senate has been moving quickly on the nominees it can agree on: earlier this week it confirmed Daniel Domenico to the Tenth Circuit in a 51-46 vote, one of several confirmations the White House has pushed through since the election.
But the arithmetic is tightening. Democrats will hold a 56-44 majority in the next Senate after Mary Peltola’s victory in Alaska, and the window for confirming contested nominees closes when the new Congress is sworn in on 3 January.
Cornyn, who lost a primary to a Trump-backed challenger earlier this year, is among the outgoing Republicans whose cooperation the White House needs most. His refusal to return Gaiser’s blue slip leaves the Dallas vacancy in limbo, with no clear path for the nomination to reach the Judiciary Committee for a vote.
What happens next
For now, Gaiser’s nomination remains pending, with no hearing scheduled and no indication from the White House that it intends to withdraw him. Cornyn’s preferred candidate, Fahey, has not been formally nominated, and it is unclear whether the administration would accept a substitution with so little time left in the session.
The standoff also raises a wider question for the White House: whether other home-state senators will use the blue-slip tradition to block nominees they were not consulted on, and how many of the remaining vacancies can realistically be filled before Democrats take the gavel.
What is clear is that the Senate’s advice-and-consent role, often described as a formality in the rush to fill the courts, is being asserted in unusually public fashion — by a member of the president’s own party.
Sources: Reuters and The Associated Press.