Advertise with NationWire
728 × 90 Leaderboard
Advertise Here
U.S. News

Judge Refuses to Pause Ruling That L.A.’s Top Federal Prosecutor Serves Unlawfully

Advertise with NationWire
300 × 250 Medium Rectangle
Advertise Here

A federal judge has refused to pause his ruling that Bill Essayli is unlawfully serving as the top federal prosecutor in Los Angeles, clearing the way for Essayli to be removed from supervising two criminal cases next week unless an appeals court steps in.

Senior U.S. District Judge J. Michael Seabright, a Hawaii judge hearing the Los Angeles challenges by designation, rejected the Justice Department’s request to stay his 27 October order. That order found Essayli was unlawfully serving as a “de facto” United States attorney for the Central District of California and barred him from participating in or supervising two prosecutions.

The disqualification will take effect one week after the judge ruled on the stay request, meaning it bites on Monday, 23 November, unless the San Francisco-based Ninth U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals intervenes first.

A title change that did not survive scrutiny

The dispute turns on how Essayli stayed in charge of the office without a vote in the U.S. Senate, which is generally required to confirm a U.S. attorney.

Essayli, a former Republican California lawmaker appointed by the Trump administration, was sworn in as interim U.S. attorney in April 2025. Federal law caps an interim appointment at 120 days. When that limit approached, Essayli resigned from the post. Then-Attorney General Pam Bondi then appointed him as a “special attorney” and designated him first assistant U.S. attorney, an arrangement that allowed him to keep running the office without Senate confirmation.

Seabright ruled that the switch of titles did not lawfully keep Essayli in charge. In his October order, he concluded that the administration could not bypass the federal appointment requirements by assigning Essayli successive titles and delegating to him the powers of the office’s top prosecutor.

The Justice Department has appealed to the Ninth Circuit and warned that the ruling could disrupt thousands of cases in the district. In refusing the stay, Seabright said the government had failed to demonstrate it would suffer specific harm from the order taking effect and faced a low likelihood of success on appeal. He also described as unsupported the department’s claim that the dispute could touch roughly 5,000 matters in the Central District of California.

Two cases, not the whole office

The order is narrower than the headlines may suggest. It bars Essayli from two criminal prosecutions only: a felon-in-possession firearms case and a case concerning property stolen from an interstate shipment.

Seabright did not dismiss the indictments in either case. Both were also signed by career prosecutors who hold their posts lawfully, so the prosecutions themselves can continue without Essayli’s involvement.

Essayli has vowed to fight the ruling. After the October decision, he said the Supreme Court would ultimately decide the matter and that he remained first assistant U.S. attorney and continued running the office in the meantime. The department’s appeal is now before the Ninth Circuit, which will decide whether the disqualification order stands while the wider legal question is litigated.

A test case for the whole appointment strategy

The Los Angeles fight is not an isolated dispute. Seabright’s decision follows a recent Ninth Circuit ruling that invalidated the same title-change mechanism used in Nevada for prosecutor Sigal Chattah. That question is already before the Supreme Court in United States v. Jackson, No. 26-304, filed on 8 September, in which Solicitor General D. John Sauer asks the justices to reverse the Chattah ruling.

The outcome could shape how the Justice Department staffs U.S. attorney offices across the country. At least three prosecutors appointed by the Trump administration through the same route have faced legal challenges to their authority, and the courts’ answers have so far gone against the government.

For now, the immediate consequence is limited but concrete. Unless the Ninth Circuit acts, Los Angeles’ top federal prosecutor will be barred from two cases next Monday, and the Justice Department will have to defend its appointment strategy in an appeals court that has already rejected the same approach once.

Sources: Bloomberg Law reported the stay denial; the Los Angeles Times reported the judge’s refusal to delay the ruling.

Advertise with NationWire
320 × 50 Mobile Banner
Advertise Here

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *