Florida Attorney General Declares Bump-Stock Ban Unconstitutional
Florida Attorney General James Uthmeier has declared the state’s 2018 ban on bump stocks unconstitutional, announcing on Friday that his office will no longer defend convictions under the law. The decision, set out in a formal legal opinion issued on 13 November, marks a sharp break with eight years of state policy on a measure passed in the aftermath of the Parkland school shooting.
Uthmeier said Floridians continue to face arrest and prosecution under the ban, and argued that the statute is written so broadly that it restricts trigger enhancements used by gun owners for lawful purposes. “Today, my office issued a legal opinion recognizing the law as unconstitutional under the Second Amendment, and this office will not defend a conviction under the statute going forward,” he wrote in a post on X.
The announcement does not repeal the ban. The law remains on the books, and no court has struck it down. But the attorney general’s stance changes how the state will handle appeals involving people convicted under it.
What the opinion says
Uthmeier’s opinion addresses Florida Statute section 790.222, which bans bump-fire stocks — devices that harness a rifle’s recoil to let a shooter fire a semiautomatic weapon far more rapidly. His office concluded that the prohibition “violates the Second Amendment and cannot be lawfully enforced by Executive Branch officials in Florida.”
The opinion applies the U.S. Supreme Court’s text-and-history test for Second Amendment cases, set out in New York State Rifle & Pistol Association v. Bruen, and leans on the court’s 2024 ruling in Garland v. Cargill. In that case, the court held that a semiautomatic rifle fitted with a bump stock is not a “machine gun” under federal law, because it does not fire more than one shot “by a single function of the trigger.”
Uthmeier concluded that the state’s ban, which covers an entire category of firearm accessories, cannot be reconciled with that framework. His office’s legal opinion also notes that the federal Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives removed bump-stock language from its machine-gun regulations with effect from 6 May 2026.
The 2018 law and Parkland
Florida’s bump-stock ban was enacted in 2018 as part of the Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School Public Safety Act, known as Senate Bill 7026. Then-Governor Rick Scott, now a U.S. senator, signed the package weeks after the mass shooting at the Parkland school, which left 17 people dead.
Under section 790.222, importing, transferring, distributing, selling, possessing or giving away a bump-fire stock is a third-degree felony, punishable by up to five years in prison. The law has not been widely used since it was passed, and reporting suggests that only a small number of people have ever been charged under it. Skyeler “Bleau” Jackson, 24, is believed to have been the first person charged under the statute.
The politics around the measure have also shifted. Governor-elect Byron Donalds voted against the original legislation when he served in the Florida House, and the attorney general’s announcement comes as the state’s Republican leadership moves further away from the gun-control package passed in 2018. A bill to repeal the ban died in committee earlier this year.
What changes — and what does not
The most important limit on Uthmeier’s announcement is that an attorney general’s opinion is advisory. It does not bind the courts, and it does not repeal a statute. Section 790.222 remains part of Florida law until lawmakers repeal it or a court issues a binding ruling striking it down. Neither has happened. The full opinion is published by the attorney general’s office.
That distinction matters for anyone currently facing charges. Prosecutors in Florida’s state attorney offices are not automatically bound by the attorney general’s view, and existing convictions are not automatically invalidated.
The development also fits a wider national pattern. Federal gun policy has been in flux since the Supreme Court’s Bruen decision, with cases testing the limits of state restrictions working their way through the courts. Amtrak’s decision to allow guns on its trains from January 2027 and the Justice Department’s lawsuit over concealed-carry permits in Glendale are among the disputes now testing where the line falls.
What to watch next
The immediate question is how prosecutors and trial courts respond. If state attorneys decline to pursue bump-stock cases, or if judges cite the opinion in dismissing them, the ban could become a dead letter in practice even while it stays on the statute books.
The Legislature is the other audience. Lawmakers could repeal the provision outright, leave it in place and let the courts decide, or revisit the broader 2018 package. For now, the attorney general has made his position plain: in his view, the ban is unconstitutional, and his office will not stand behind it in court. The dispute follows a separate Florida dispute over a cancelled St Patrick’s Day parade in Delray Beach, and whether the bump-stock question ends in the Legislature or in court, it is now a live legal fight — not a settled one.